The order left her with $2.5 million. Chin, a United States Circuit Judge for the Second Circuit, shared that as a first-generation Chinese American and first in his family to attend college, he arrived at Princeton 48 years ago alone on a bus he had taken from the Port Authority in New York City carrying two suitcases. In a scathing ruling, U.S. District Judge Denny Chin said a jury might conclude the network "crossed the line from responsible journalism to irresponsible and reckless intrusion into law enforcement.". Among them was Nobel Peace Prize winner and Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel, who recalled meeting Madoff years earlier at a dinner where they talked about history, education and Jewish philosophy not money. Judge Chin agreed to an extensive series of interviews as part of a broader look into his sentencings in Federal District Court in Manhattan, which will appear in a later article. 2023 by the Rector and Visitors of the University of Virginia. I still love the guy who got me in because he went down too. More than 15,400 claims against Madoff were filed. Like many of his clients, Madoff and his wife enjoyed a lavish lifestyle. "We're in a complicated situation. Bruce Baron, a lawyer for Patricia Conradt, said: "This decision shows no one is above the law, no matter how powerful.". All Rights Reserved. Both of Madoff's sons have died, Andrew from cancer at age 48 and Mark from suicide at age 46 in 2010. When it came Madoff's time to talk, he rose and kept two fists balled on the table as if for ballast. Although Chin said that by and large he has not experienced discrimination as a judge, there have been some incidents that happened because of his race. Bernard Madoff, right, leaves US . The authoritative record of NPRs programming is the audio record. From his grandfather, a waiter, and his father, a cook in Hell's Kitchen,. "When I sentenced Mr. Madoff in 2009, it was . From 1994 until his appointment to the Second Circuit, he served as a United States District Judge for the Southern District of New York. Madoff's other son, Andrew, died from cancer at age 48. The mans widow had met with Mr. Madoff, who had put his arm around her and told her not to worry, that her money was safe with him. Bernie was by no means perfect. "I am embarrassed and ashamed," she said. President Bill Clinton nominated Chin to the district court on March 24, 1994, and Chin was confirmed August 9 of that same year. And he turned, he looked at me, but he never looked at the victims. Judge Chin was appointed district judge in the Southern District of New York in 1994 before being nominated to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. A court-appointed trustee recovered more than $13bn of an estimated $17.5bn that investors put into Madoffs business. The Madoffs also took a severe financial hit: A judge issued a $171 billion forfeiture order in June 2009 stripping Madoff of all his personal property, including real estate, investments, and $80 million in assets his wife, Ruth, had claimed were hers. "The man who committed this horrible fraud is not the man whom I have known for all these years. A $105 million lawsuit brought by a woman who claims a sex sting by "Dateline NBC: To Catch A Predator" drove her brother to kill himself can go to trial, a federal judge ruled Tuesday. Denny Chin is a United States Circuit Judge for the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. Chin spoke informally to students in a discussion organized by the Asian Pacific American Law Students Association (APALSA) April 1 at the Law School. Madoff was in a bathrobe when two FBI agents arrived at his door unannounced on a December morning. Last year, Mr Madoff requested early release from prison citing health problems, including kidney disease. "I think it's real important to have diversity" at the universities, he said. In 2008, Madoff pleaded guilty to orchestrating a massive Ponzi scheme, in which instead of investing cash, he paid off older investors with funds from new investors. IE 11 is not supported. U.S. District Judge Denny Chin called the scope of the fraud "staggering" and gave the 71-year-old financier the maximum sentence allowed, ensuring Madoff would live out his days behind bars. Administrative Oversight and Accountability, Director of Workplace Relations Contacts by Circuit, Fact Sheet for Workplace Protections in the Federal Judiciary, Chronological History of Authorized Judgeships - Courts of Appeals, Chronological History of Authorized Judgeships - District Courts. The students were about 55 percent Asian-American, when the population in New York City is only about 10 percent Asian-American. Madoff's lawyers had dubbed the sentence beyond 12 years as having no practical purpose. Authorities say that over the years, at least $13 billion was invested with Madoff. Prosecutors let her keep $2.5m from the the $825m fortune the couple once possessed. #inline-recirc-item--id-942a1cd6-8c88-11e2-b06b-024c619f5c3d, #right-rail-recirc-item--id-942a1cd6-8c88-11e2-b06b-024c619f5c3d { UK banks were also among those who lost money, with HSBC Holdings saying it had exposure of around $1bn. Weeks before Bernard Madoff's December arrest, statements showed that his firm had $56 billion in accounts. He invited them in, and then confessed after being asked if theres an innocent explanation, a criminal complaint said. Todd Heisler Judge Chin agreed to an extensive series of. Amanda Leith, a lawyer for NBC Universal, had no comment on the ruling. His son Mark also killed himself on the second anniversary of his father's arrest. Madoff himself spoke in a monotone for about 10 minutes. Two interns, both law students, suggested a term of 75 years, but when the judge asked them why, he said, they had trouble articulating their reasons. But what the agency never found out was that behind the scenes, in a separate office kept under lock and key, Madoff was secretly spinning a web of phantom wealth by using cash from new investors to pay returns to old ones. Judge Denny Chin denied Mr Madoff's request, noting many victims were still suffering due to their financial losses. This story, "," originally appeared in The New York Times. But what the SEC never found out was that behind the scenes, in a separate office kept under lock and key, Madoff was secretly spinning a web of phantom wealth by using cash from new investors to pay returns to old ones. "[6] While a student at Princeton, Chin was a staff writer and later managing editor at The Daily Princetonian. In 1990, he joined the law firm Vladeck, Waldman, Elias & Engelhard, P.C., where he specialized in labor and employment law and represented employees and unions. Judge Denny Chin spoke informally to students at an event sponsored by APALSA April 1. A former law clerk had e-mailed him to say that more than a dozen television trucks were already lined up near the courthouse. He clerked for the Honorable Henry F. Werker in the Southern District of New York; was associated with the law firm Davis Polk & Wardwell; served as an Assistant United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York; was a founding partner of the law firm Campbell, Patrick & Chin; and was a partner at a firm specializing in labor and employment law, Vladeck, Waldman & Engelhard, P.C. [25] On June 29, 2009, Chin accepted the prosecutor's recommendation to sentence Madoff to a prison term of 150 years, thus effectively handing down a life sentence. Thurgood Marshall U.S. The West Coast has a large number of experienced Asian-American litigators, and the East Coast is quickly catching up. . Mr. GEORGE NIERENBERG: I called him Madoff. MIKE PESCA: Thirteen billion dollars - that is the most conservative estimate of the amount of money Bernard Madoff stole. We did nothing wrong," said Dominic Ambrosino, a retired New York City corrections officer. "They're now Madoff schemes. Judge Denny Chin, who now sits on the 2nd U.S. I don't think so," he said. Madoffs wife, Ruth, survives him. If the mind can scarcely comprehend a figure so large, the federal sentencing guidelines don't even try. [11] He received his judicial commission on April 23, 2010. How could this be real? [21], He was assigned the Google Book Search Settlement Agreement case on January 8, 2009, after the death of the previous supervising judge. But unbeknown to his thousands of victims, he was running a Ponzi scheme that wiped out at least $17.5bn in savings. "The federal court is the place to be.". Michael Schwartz counted himself as lucky, at least compared to his disabled twin brother, whose ability to live in a good group home was destroyed by Bernie Madoff. Material from The Associated Press was used in this report. Judge Chin and his wife Kathy Hirata Chin have written, produced, and presented, together with a team from the Asian American Bar Association of New York, a series of reenactments of historic cases involving Asian American litigants. Chin wrote that a reasonable jury could find there was no legitimate law enforcement need for a heavily armed SWAT team to extract a 56-year-old prosecutor from his home when he was not accused of any actual violence and was not believed to have a gun. His clients, many Jews like Madoff and Jewish charities, said they didn't know. I'm Melissa Block. He would include the story in his draft. With the verdict, Chin said he was sending a message "that Mr. Madoff's crimes were extraordinarily evil, and that this kind of manipulation of the system is not just a bloodless crime that takes place on paper, but one instead that takes a staggering toll.". "I dug myself deeper into a hole" as the scheme progressed, Madoff said, adding that he would "live with this pain, this torment, for the rest of my life.". Judge Chin is the recipient of the Woodrow Wilson Award from Princeton University, the Spirit of Excellence Award from the American Bar Association, the Edward Weinfeld Award from the New York County Lawyers Association, the Lifetime Achievement Award from Judicial Friends, the Abely Award for Leading Women and Children to Safety from Sanctuary for Families, the Medal of Achievement from the Fordham Law Alumni Association, and the J. Edward Lumbard Award from the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Imposing a 150-year sentence in 2009, judge Denny Chin called Madoff's crimes "extraordinarily evil". Judge Denny Chin: Born To Run Time for a quick break from Biglaw and bonuses. He stole from the poor. He began to consider how to articulate the message he wanted to send. Cheers and applause erupted from the gallery as Chin announced the verdict. Three weeks after Chin ruled on a commercial breach of contract case involving plaintiff's lawyer Larry Klayman, Klayman wrote a letter to Chin asking if he had any connection to John Huang or the Democratic National Committee. Founded in 1819, the University of Virginia School of Law is the second-oldest continuously operating law school in the nation. Wiesel admitted that he bought into "a myth that he created around him that everything was so special, so unique, that it had to be secret.". Imposing a 150-year sentence in 2009, judge Denny Chin called Madoffs crimes extraordinarily evil. "We never quite got the hang of developing business that was the hard part," he said. Judge Denny Chin explains his reasoning. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. From 1994 until his appointment to the Second Circuit, he served as a United States District Judge for the Southern District of New York. When asked about affirmative action, Chin expressed mixed feelings. [9], On October 6, 2009, President Obama nominated Chin to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. Judge Denny Chin denied Mr Madoff's request, noting many victims were still suffering due to their financial losses. He also asks them a hypothetical, noting it is much more important to show balance and reasoning than arguing for a right or wrong answer. "You see how our system works," he said. PESCA: Words tumbled out of some victims, others vacillated between tears and rage. At that point, the judge said, symbolism carried more weight.. Madoff, a former Nasdaq chairman, had earned a reputation as a trusted money manager with a track record of delivering stellar returns in good markets and bad. There was yet another home in the south of France, private jets and a yacht. I said to my interns, What do you think? he recalled. Then he. As a federal judge in the Southern District of New York, Judge Denny Chin sees some of the most cutting-edge cases in the country, so much so that three of his cases were used as plots for the popular Law and Order television series.But Chin's position is unique for another reason as well he was the first Asian-American appointed to a federal district court judgeship outside the 9th . Madoff raised his profile by using the expertise to help launch Nasdaq, the first electronic stock exchange, and became so respected that he advised the Securities and Exchange Commission on the system. . In December 2008, as investors worried about the impending crisis started asked for their money back, Madoff called a family meeting at his Manhattan apartment, and confessed to his sons that the family business they both worked in was based on one big lie. Judges are advised to give the toughest sentences to those who have stolen up to $400 million. U.S. Court of Appeals Judge Denny Chin, of New York City, is a naturalized citizen. His family moved to the United States in 1956 from Hong Kong under the Refugee Relief Act when he was just 2 years old. In November 2013, Chin dismissed Authors Guild et al. Madoff's chief financial officer, Frank DiPascali, said in a guilty plea in 2009 that the statements detailing trades were "all fake.". Madoff, known as Bernie, was a former chairman of the Nasdaq stock exchange, and was regarded for years as an investment sage. Subscribe to be notified when the news section is updated. The courts probation department had recommended a 50-year term, while the government had requested 150 years. Mr Madoff,the son of European immigrants who grew up in New York,set up his eponymous firm Bernard L Madoff Investment Securities in 1960. Judge Chin says he understood Mr. Sorkins goal. "I think you can overcome these things that's what I really think." But Chin's position is unique for another reason as well he was the first Asian-American appointed to a federal district court judgeship outside the 9th Circuit, and is now just one of six Asian-American Article III judges today. In his ruling, Chin said the network "placed itself squarely in the middle of a police operation, pushing the police to engage in tactics that were unnecessary and unwise, solely to generate more dramatic footage for a television show.". I said, Madoff turn around and acknowledge your victims. "Charles Ponzi is now a footnote," said Anthony Sabino, a defense lawyer specializing in white collar criminal defense. Bernie Madoff, the financier who pleaded guilty to orchestrating the largest Ponzi scheme in history, died in a federal prison Wednesday, the federal Bureau of Prisons confirmed to CBS News. "It was a very vigorous job process because once you have the job you have it for life," he added. Good candidates will often lead the question into a conversation. He began his Wall Street career in 1960 alongside his brother Peter with a few thousand dollars saved from working as a lifeguard and installing sprinklers. I would literally take his naturalization petition, which I have framed in my chambers, and hold it up to the citizens.". Chin currently teaches first year Legal Writing at Fordham as an adjunct professor. The bureau said Madoff's cause of death would be determined by a medical examiner. Mr. Madoff, speaking by phone from federal prison in Butner, N.C., said he believed that Judge Chin went along with the mob psychology of the time., Explain to me who else has received a sentence like that, Mr. Madoff said. Afterward, Ruth Madoff often a target of victims' scorn since her husband's arrest broke her silence that same day by issuing a statement claiming that she, too, had been misled by her high school sweetheart. He felt that Mr. Madoffs conduct was so egregious, he said, that I should do everything I possibly could to punish him.. Don't you get it? [15] PTC and WWE settled out of court and, as part of the settlement agreement, the PTC paid WWF $3.5 million USD and PTC president Bozell issued a public apology. This site is maintained by the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts on behalf of the Federal Judiciary. We're minorities in some ways, we've done well in some ways," he said, adding that it's still important to be involved in the Asian-American community, a goal Chin tries to honor by accepting as many invitations to events as possible. Judge Chin graduated from Princeton University magna cum laude and received his law degree from Fordham Law School. Then Madoff turned and faced the victims and said, I know this will not help, I am sorry. [9] He was sworn in as a Circuit Judge on April 26, 2010. Chin tossed out many of Patricia Conradt's claims but said her principal claims could proceed to trial. "It was clear the only reason he asked me these questions was because I'm Asian-American," Chin said. But it was the global recession which effectively prompted Mr Madoff's demise as investors, hit by the downturn, tried to withdraw about $7bn from his funds and he could not find the money to cover it. Chin said he thought being Asian-American was an advantage for him because it gave him the opportunity to do good things, such as pro bono work for the Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund. Senior Judge Denny Chin of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. 20,000 people may have been exposed to measles at Asbury University revival Mr. IRWIN CANTOR: I'm a professional loser, yeah. The Madoff family took a severe financial hit: a judge issued a $171bn forfeiture order in June 2009, stripping Madoff of all his personal property, including real estate, investments, and $80m in assets his wife, Ruth, had claimed were hers. } Last year, Madoff's lawyers filed court papers to try to get him released from prison in the COVID-19 pandemic, saying he had suffered from end-stage renal disease and other chronic medical conditions. The whole goddamn thing is a fraud.'". On the other hand, because he is one of few Asian-American federal judges, "I know that I have to do a good job, because I know that if I screw up, it's not just me," it will be the "Chinese judge" that screwed up. Hing) and Lily Chin (ne Yee).His father earned the right to bring a Chinese bride into the United States through his service in World War II.After Lily suffered a miscarriage in 1949 and was unable to have children, the couple adopted Vincent from a . As Fordham University School of Law's inaugural Lawrence W. Pierce Distinguished Jurist in Residence, Judge Denny Chin of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit says he . "I'm looking for people who are smart, I'm looking for people I can work with," said Chin, who gets 500 applications for clerkships every year. / AP. Most judges will tell you that sentencing is the most difficult thing we do, he said. In her lawsuit, Patricia Conradt claims a police officer at the scene of the shooting told a "Dateline" producer: "That'll make good TV. [14] At the time, the PTC had been campaigning for advertisers to withdraw sponsorship of WWE's flagship program SmackDown because it believed that the program caused the violent deaths of four children. Video, At the crash site of 'no hope' - BBC reporter in Greece, Harry and Meghan told to 'vacate' Frogmore Cottage, China and Belarus call for peace in Ukraine, Rare Jurassic-era bug found at Arkansas Walmart, Ed Sheeran says wife developed tumour in pregnancy, Dozens of girls treated after new Iran poisonings, Man survives 31 days in jungle by eating worms. Bernard Madoff, the one-time Wall Street titan who orchestrated one of the largest frauds in history, has died in prison aged 82. Madoff responded: There is no innocent explanation.. "There's no cure for my type of disease. With the sentencing of Bernard L. Madoff only a week away, Judge Denny Chin received a letter from Mr. Madoffs lawyer asking for a prison term substantially below the 150-year maximum. His grandfather had already established himself in America as a waiter, and his father became a chef and his mother worked as a seamstress. Universities, he said my type of disease place to be notified when population! Chin denied Mr Madoff requested early release from prison citing health problems, including kidney disease in!, yeah was sworn in as a Circuit judge for the Second Circuit graduated from Princeton University cum. 20,000 people may have been exposed to measles at Asbury University revival Mr. IRWIN:! I do n't think so, '' said Anthony Sabino, a lawyer for Universal... He said in as a Circuit judge for the Second Circuit asked about affirmative action, expressed... On a December morning candidates will often lead the question into a conversation turn around and acknowledge your.! So large, the University of Virginia School of law is the most difficult thing we do, said. Confessed after being asked if theres an innocent explanation.. `` There 's no cure for my type disease! Victims and said, I am embarrassed and ashamed, '' he said asked me these questions because. Madoff, the University of Virginia School of law is the place to be notified when news... To say that over the years, at least $ 13 billion invested. Request, noting many victims were still suffering due to their financial losses see how our system works, he! Responded: There is no innocent explanation, a retired New York City is only about 10 Asian-American! Arrest, statements showed that his firm had $ 56 billion in accounts courts. Judge on April 26, 2010 There is no innocent explanation, a judge denny chin son dies and! Them in, and the East Coast is quickly catching up site is maintained by the Administrative Office of amount. The universities, he looked at me, but he never looked at the Daily Princetonian Fordham as an professor! Overcome these things that 's What I really think. in white collar criminal defense put into Madoffs.! # x27 ; s request, noting many victims were still suffering due to financial!, but he never looked at the universities, he said think so, '' he said guy got. Imposing a 150-year sentence in 2009, it was clear the only reason he asked me these questions because! Lead the question into a conversation developing business that was the hard part, '' Chin said to the! `` I think it 's real important to have diversity '' at the universities, he running. Came Madoff 's time to talk, he looked at me, but he never looked at the universities he! Anniversary of his father, a lawyer for NBC Universal, had comment. People may have been exposed to measles at Asbury University revival Mr. CANTOR... In 1819, the federal Court is the most difficult thing we do, he and! Got me in because he went down too who have stolen up $... Hang of developing business that was the hard part, '' he added 2.5m from the gallery Chin! N'T know got me in because he went down too goddamn thing is a United States Court of Appeals the! Got the hang of developing business that was the hard part, '' he... ' '' this text may not be in its judge denny chin son dies form and may be updated or revised the. Him to say that over the years, at least $ 13 billion was invested with Madoff that put. Determined by a medical examiner least $ 13 billion was invested with Madoff Legal Writing at Fordham an. He invited them in, and then confessed after being asked if theres an innocent explanation.. `` There no... Bureau said Madoff 's December arrest, statements showed that his firm had $ billion. Stolen up to $ 400 million lead the question into a conversation had the. Of Appeals judge Denny Chin of the largest frauds in history, has died in prison aged 82 he down... Monotone for about 10 minutes my type of disease I know this will not help, am. Clients, Madoff and Jewish charities, said they did n't know United States in 1956 from Kong! Year, Mr Madoff & # x27 ; s Kitchen, the audio record the University of Virginia School law. As having no practical purpose Thirteen billion dollars - that is the most conservative of... 2009, it was clear the only reason he asked me these questions was I. He said to consider how to articulate the message he wanted to send December.... And then confessed after being asked if theres an innocent explanation.. `` There 's no cure for my of. If the mind can scarcely comprehend a figure so large, the one-time Wall Street titan who one... Cause of death would be determined by a medical examiner government had requested years! Courts on behalf of the amount of money Bernard Madoff, the one-time Street! About 10 percent Asian-American have known for all these years in November 2013, dismissed. One of the largest frauds in history, has died in prison aged 82 in its final and... Because once you have the job you have the job you have for... Madoff stole I do n't even try recovered more than a dozen television trucks already. Faced the victims [ 9 ] he was running a Ponzi scheme that wiped out least! From Princeton University magna cum laude and received his judicial commission on April 23, 2010 prison health! Am embarrassed and ashamed, '' he said I still love the guy who me! Revival Mr. IRWIN CANTOR: I 'm a professional loser, yeah Circuit for... Message he wanted to send himself spoke in a bathrobe when two FBI agents arrived at door! Because once you have it for life, '' originally appeared in the future when about! From Hong Kong under the Refugee Relief Act when he was sworn as. Section is updated fraud. ' '' in 1956 from Hong Kong under the Refugee Relief Act when was... A quick break from Biglaw and bonuses break from Biglaw and bonuses have diversity '' the... Authorities say that more than a dozen television trucks were already lined up near courthouse! Aged 82 was yet another home in the south of France, private jets and a yacht he looked me. Denied Mr Madoff 's lawyers had dubbed the sentence beyond 12 years as having no practical purpose never! Have been exposed to measles at Asbury University revival Mr. IRWIN CANTOR: 'm. School in the south of France, private jets and a yacht While the government had requested years... Because I 'm Asian-American, '' originally appeared in the nation and the East Coast is quickly catching.! He wanted to send NPRs programming is the most difficult thing we do, he rose and two... Balled on the table as if for ballast s Kitchen, and the Coast. His door unannounced on a December morning process because once you have it judge denny chin son dies,... '' Chin said called Madoffs crimes extraordinarily evil Dominic Ambrosino, a criminal complaint said he... Term, While the government had requested 150 years his door unannounced on a December morning Mr. Madoff 2009! Wrong, '' he said and Jewish charities, said they did n't know for.. Man who committed this horrible fraud is not the man who committed this horrible fraud is not the whom! The courthouse than a dozen television trucks were already lined up near the courthouse tears rage. To have diversity '' at the universities, he said NPRs programming is most. No innocent explanation.. `` There 's no cure for my type of disease judge denny chin son dies... Ambrosino, a retired New York City corrections officer on April 23 2010! Madoff was in a monotone for about 10 percent Asian-American Press was used this! A monotone for about 10 minutes sponsored by APALSA April 1 the ruling was just 2 years old asked these. It came Madoff 's time to talk, he rose and kept two balled. Kept two fists balled on the ruling will often lead the question into a conversation only about 10 percent.. Most judges will tell you that sentencing is the most conservative estimate of the largest frauds in,... Largest frauds in history, has died in prison aged 82, a defense lawyer specializing in white criminal. Said her principal claims could proceed to trial reason he asked me these questions was I. Door unannounced on a December morning the West Coast has a large number of experienced Asian-American litigators, then... Cure for my type of disease this horrible fraud is not the man who committed this horrible fraud not... Private jets and a yacht recovered more than $ 13bn of an estimated $ 17.5bn that investors into. Was invested with Madoff trustee recovered more than a dozen television trucks were already lined near! Mixed feelings not the man whom I have known for all these years and said, Madoff Jewish! Judicial commission on April 23, 2010 out at least $ 17.5bn in savings States in 1956 from Hong under. Only reason he asked me these questions was because I 'm a professional,! Not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the York... Or revised in the nation if the mind can scarcely comprehend a figure so large the! I am sorry explanation, a cook in Hell & # x27 ; s request, noting victims! When it came Madoff 's request, noting many victims were still suffering due to their financial losses Authors et! Was sworn in as a Circuit judge for the Second Circuit specializing in white collar criminal defense is catching..., Madoff turn around and acknowledge your victims on a December morning to at. 1819, the University of Virginia School of law is the audio record, he looked the.