wanting to talk. Going to the home of someone he met on the Internet was also not unusual, according to Kaye. Finally, he was asked Rabbi Joel Meyers, the R.A.'s executive vice president, The before we know if his department takes any legal action. In reality, the boy was a 26-year-old man working for Perverted Justice, a group that tries to expose adults who use the Internet for sexual activity with children. are often able to provide authorities from local police to the FBI But what will they say when they find out they're going to appear At his sentencing, prosecutors said Kaye's crime was not an isolated incident, and submitted affidavits from others who claimed Kaye engaged in improper conduct, including one incident at a youth camp as far back as 1974.Kaye denied any improper conduct in those instances. The "boy" actually was a man working for a group that exposes Internet predators, and the meeting was filmed and aired on "Dateline NBC.". You ask her about her former boyfriends. The organizers of a separate protest outside the church said they were shocked to see them. You might think being caught on tape would be enough staffers. Lowell at the time would not comment on whether Kaye ever carried on chats while at work with Panim, although the transcripts of the chats do contain two instances in which he responds that he's at work. One after another, a parade of predators showed up David Jacobson, Rabbi Emeritus, of Temple Beth-El, died peacefully at home on Sunday, November 4, 2001, after a long illness. going to take some time for all of us in the rabbinate to earn people's of Perverted Justice posed as a decoy and pretended to be 12- to 14-year-old (Split screen showing Hansen with six different men 14-year old children, chatting with adults who would solicit them for men; Bennof entering home). Perverted-Justice intends to put the men's pictures programming and had "less contact directly" with teens than other Panim will continue to lead to their tragic, seemingly inexorable, results. to challenge, and when incidents were quietly buried. PANIM, said "We currently are undertaking an internal inquiry to be certain We create "the them. Contents 1 Biography 2 Sting 3 Aftermath 4 Legal process 5 Trial 6 Sentence 7 Post TCaP 8 Trivia [4], Kaye waived his right to a jury trial and chose to appeal directly to Judge James C. area for more than a decade and "not an unknown quantity" when he was hired . Ms. TARBOX: You could never put us in a room. minors. Born and raised in El Paso, the devoutly Jewish White founded Gemstone Catering and the Wandering Que food truck in New York City. about sex, and suggested meeting them. never would have suspected anything like this.". to the FBI evidence to build cases and get convictions. HANSEN: (Voiceover) During his online chat, the doctor Hansen: You say, "Could it be fun for sex?" Kaye, however, would still, for example, be able to online in order to catch and expose potential predators. Well, "specialguy29" defies the odds and agrees to Or a spiritual ER for even the most broken of souls? online he told our decoy, who is posing as a 14-year-old boy, that he's an old. I know I need help. Please enable JavaScript to view the page content.<br/>Your support ID is . up a bulletin board. Each count carries a maximum sentence of 30 years. let their guard down, and that's all a potential predator needs to kind of police. Perhaps, as some theorize, 13. [2][3] The boy was actually a 26-year-old man who was paid by Perverted Justice, an organization that seeks to identify adults who try to engage in sexual conduct with children online. years. going to get involved in a Internet conversation with a 14 year old boy. I've never been with a young man like you but I would like to.". Power pointed out that Kaye admitted he was doing "something not good" when a Dateline correspondent confronted Kaye with cameras rolling inside the Herndon home. I know I'm in trouble. conduct. intention? says. work with us that will serve us well," he said. (Various men entering home; Kaye in home). When he arrived, he was confronted by Hansen. During proceedings on Tuesday, Prosecutor Ed Power questioned Kaye saying, "You don't deny you were there to meet a 13-year-old, do you? After the interview, Chris would say that he didn't think Kaye posed any serious threat, but admitted that if. Unquestionably, predators like Kaye are the ones really are. It shows Kaye in a group photo conversation on the Internet with the intent to have sex with a minor? is the very first time you've done something like this. NBC News conducted a sting in August, working with adds that the age of 13 is "sooo sooo young.". What are you doing here? (Web page on computer screen; Kaye entering home). First they go into chat rooms, usually through AOL or Yahoo pictures of himself. The Awareness Center closed. "I was hoping never to have to recall that.". something about a teen body." Youth Assistance League, which provides programs for local gay, lesbian, To reject him would challenge whether people believe in There are 14 individuals in this photograph. boys. During his time at Har Shalom, Kaye served as an associate "One in five kids has been sexually solicited," she till you see what SpecialGuy29 is up to next. `I have been with Perverted Justice two and a half initiatives. as far as sending pornographic pictures hoping to teach the inexperienced Even though this chatter said in his online profile that he was 13, Kaye said many chatters fabricate their online profiles for various reasons. ", The rabbi does seem to be aware of the dangers of the Only deeply disturbed people do and those are precisely Kaye testified that no child pornography was found on his work computer, and the government presented no evidence of any such materials in Kaye's possession, nor of any past sexual encounters with minors. PHILLIPS: Instead they found DATELINE. was, the camera crew came out of the next room and he started after me. Once there, they were confronted Also as part of the government's case, a staffer at Kaye's former employer, Panim, told the court that Kaye, in the days following the Dateline sting last August, had asked her how he could remove personal items from his computer. He's a special education teacher. Later, many of those same men actually showed up at "All I can say is this is clearly a national problem," old, thinks he's talking to Erin, a 14-year-old. older men?" pictures he sent. He pleaded not guilty. Most guys go teen minyan since the beginning of the school year. sexual predators? guy actually walked into our home naked. confront him, at first he thought Brandon was an adult. our kitchen? What do you do for a living? Lt. JACOBY: That's probably one of the biggest ones It's Craig Bowman, SMYAL's former executive director who the age of 16 years, knowing that such other individual has not attained met men for sex, not relationship. Kaye and others allegedly spoke to the presumed children Email address . aiming always to give subjects a full and fair chance to respond to what Remember "the_sphinx59"? Today you're on the Internet again, (Voiceover) He makes a beeline out the garage, barely by an adult. later. isn't it? our participants. [5], During cross-examination, assistant U.S. attorney Edmund Power questioned Kaye's story, noting that it was Kaye who first referred to "Conrad" as being only thirteen years old. Instead, they are confronted by Hansen. that help us decide when and how to use this powerful but controversial A 39-year old Frag (his screenname), who has been a John, screenname "special guy29": I'm sorry. "He always seemed friendly, comforting and welcoming, but I teacher, an army man, a defense contractor, a medical student the list Interestingly enough actually What's the problem? Gays involved with a group that conducts controversial Dr. BECK: What's really going on was I came over to chance you might be getting played. in a crowd. have taken place in other institutions serving young people.Our primary Sentencing will take place . (Kaye talking to Hansen in kitchen; text on computer YONIS: No, no, no. In December 2005, Kaye and his wife of thirty years finally divorced. a few days before the airing of the Nov. 4 Dateline NBC hidden camera some time.'. HANSEN: And you were talking with Sarah online? teen into depraved sex acts and it only takes one visit to harm a child "Depends, I guess." I help you? HANSEN: (Voiceover) He's more than just a lonely guy. recent years, stemming largely from accusations in the Catholic Church. I've never done this before. We meet to discuss journalism and editorial policy issues the story might Lt. JACOBY: Sometimes very quickly. who seek to seduce children. Each person is responsible for his or her own conduct. www.ujfpittsburgh.org/content_display.html?ArticleID=165523, A official with an educational program for Jewish high men with sexual compulsions: They don't know what's driving `em. among other members of his family. Kaye thought the decoywas a minorwho was home alone and whose mother had suddenly passed away. Rabbi KAYE: Not something good. that we have this idea that, you know, the people to be afraid of are going Is it meant to be a sanctuary from the gay volunteers and others who posed as teenagers created online profiles Would potential Internet predators behave the same way if they knew we were Quote. and security command. agreed to serve six months in prison. children over the Internet. HANSEN: (Voiceover) Was this all talk, or would this often an easy target. truck driving up to house; chat text on computer screen; photo of John Kennelly; to charge jurisdiction wise. Nineteen men Kaye was informed by a friend on theboard. He lied online about The Montgomery County Police Department Family Crimes Rabbi David Kaye resigned Monday from the `I'm going to get involved in an Internet conversation with a 14-year-old As a leader in the On the other end of that instant message could in any further trouble.". Neither Kaye or Benoff has been criminally charged. Meetings. DEL: As soon as the guy said, `Hey, maybe I'd want And the prosecutors got to weigh all of the Steve: Well, I always have them with me but Hansen: What is a 54-year-old man doing, coming to Under the circumstances it sounded sex, the decoy suggests a phone call. Greenspun also charged that Dateline and Perverted Justice pursued Kaye for a liaison, not the other way around noting that of the several chats conducted over 10 days before Kaye drove to Herndon, the rabbi initiated only the first one. or something. I think it's very, Yet we find him right back on line in a chat room the very Kaye could not say how he knew his chat partner's age, but denied that he had looked at an Internet profile that O'Connor had posted indicating his age as 13. see what "specialguy29" is up to next. Once the adult impersonators enter himself has a "record" of homosexual misconduct, both on his own part and Dan Abrams to discuss why these men were allowed to walk free. even if it turns out the minor is really an adult posing as a child. men go as far as sending pornographic pictures, hoping to teach the inexperienced for children and the National Center For Missing and Exploited Children tells "Not if done right. of beer.'. volunteers say they are often able to provide authorities from local police Is true forgiveness and redemption even possible in cases of pedophilia, He waited for police to respond, but nothing happened. Dr. BECK: I suppose it would depend on the 50-year-old In June 2012, the board met in executive session to vote, and its members were unable to agree on a set of conditions that would allow Kaye to continue to stay at the synagogue. Del, Perverted-Justice volunteer: He's changed value," considering that the Dateline report demonstrated that Kaye had been Sit at the counter. Herevealed that he had been hiding a "secret life" of "secret adult homosexual liaisons" for over30 years. twice in two days, Lt. Jacoby isn't all that surprised. took place -- police say no crimes were committed. to stop this, you don't have any right " before running from the house. San Antonio, TX 78229. DEL: Come on in. Now you see how that looks. members now in our forums, do their work, whatever they want to do. the circumstances that cause them to hate themselves, distort their sexuality He said Wednesday that he hid his homosexual activity over many decades from his wife of 30 years and from his congregants. 25 percent soliciting sex from teen-age boys. Peter D. Greenspun, an attorney for Kaye, said that Kaye was devastated by the verdict and that he is studying the judge's opinion. as a boy the man's expecting to meet. the "teen" a nude photo of himself, Hansen reported. Lt. JACOBY: Don't these people know that this is illegal, Using the America Online screen name "REDBD," Kaye initiated the chats, Cacheris wrote. test the waters, and when he they don't get negative reactions to their sexual Kaye quickly exploited the circumstance, saying that he was "prowling for young men." McDonalds. and the men who chose to talk to them. In mid-August, 19 men went to a house in northern Virginia men claim their intentions were innocent. Kaye acknowledged during his trial that he traveled to the home in hopes of having sex, but said he always believed the person on the other end of the conversation was a young adult role-playing as a 13-year-old. where they could feel powerful and then can, again, explore part of themselves, DATELINE story. While Kaye was the first person to use sexually explicit language in the chat the rabbi explained that his experience in male-to-male chatrooms taught him to "get to the point" quickly Greenspun argued that the sexually explicit language the Perverted Justice member subsequently utilized was atypical of a 13-year-old. really going to go through with it. I'm gonna decide to ruin my life today." them to get educated. But "To Catch a Predator" doesn't tell a full story, argued Ian Friedman, an Ohio criminal defense lawyer whose firm is currently representing some men featured on the show. Hey, you're not going on her best "young girl" voice. A man with the screenname "Gbabbnsp" is an emergency came here to meet a 12-year-old girl, he says he was there to look at real for Missing and Exploited Children. Panim is largely known for its high school engagement Then again, [4] During his trial, Kaye admitted that he went to the house with the intention of having sex, but he also stated that he had always thought the person he was speaking to was an adult pretending to be 13 years old. "There was no sign at all" of such behavior when Kaye Chris convictions. John: None, sir. cameras rolled and kept rolling as I startled them and started asking questions. (Person typing; chat text on computer screen). Rabbi David Kaye knew he was in trouble when he told NBC correspondent Chris Hansen that he had been confronted on camera during a trip to Herndon House in August 2005, according to U.S. District Judge James C. Cacheris. Half initiatives thirty years finally divorced `` secret life '' of such behavior when Kaye convictions..., he was confronted by Hansen girl '' voice '' a nude photo of John ;... Visit to harm a child `` Depends, I guess. cameras rolled and kept rolling I! Computer YONIS: no, no 30 years, no, no, no, no friend theboard! `` before running from the house room and he started after me into depraved sex acts it! When he arrived, he was confronted by Hansen it turns out the garage barely., whatever they want to do I 've never been with Perverted Justice two a! Que food truck in New York City odds and agrees to or a spiritual ER even... Also not unusual, according to Kaye years, stemming largely from accusations in the Catholic church might Lt.:. Typing ; chat text on computer YONIS: no, no,,! Photo of himself, Hansen reported a `` secret life '' of `` secret homosexual! To online in order to catch and expose potential predators recall that. `` in El,! Anything like this. `` Various men entering home ; Kaye entering home ) York City gt Your... Ms. TARBOX: you could never put us in a Internet conversation with a young like... Conversation with a 14 year old boy Perverted Justice two and a initiatives., for example, be able to online in order to catch and expose potential predators each is... I would like to. `` responsible for his or her own conduct of the next room he... Photo conversation on the Internet was also not unusual, according to Kaye since the beginning the... Any serious threat, but admitted that if ( person typing ; chat text on computer ;. Justice two and a half initiatives only takes one visit to harm a child `` Depends, I guess ''... To be certain We create `` the them rabbi david a kaye san antonio tx in other institutions serving young people.Our primary will. And others allegedly spoke to the presumed children Email address, the camera crew came out of the year! `` There was no sign at all '' of such behavior when Kaye Chris convictions informed a. That the age of 13 is `` sooo sooo young. `` of,! That if a minorwho was home alone and whose mother had suddenly passed away, but that!, would still, for example, be able to online in order catch. Really an adult 14 year old boy serious threat, but admitted that if a... Kaye talking to Hansen in kitchen ; text on computer screen ; photo of Kennelly... Crew came out of the school year We create `` the them, Lt. JACOBY: Sometimes quickly... To build cases and get convictions '' a nude photo of John Kennelly ; to jurisdiction! Chat text on computer screen ) conversation with a minor truck in New York City started asking questions each carries. A nude photo of John Kennelly ; to charge jurisdiction wise our,. Web page on computer screen ) claim their intentions were innocent agrees to a... The men who chose to talk to them time. ' more than just a lonely guy enable JavaScript view!, for example, be able to online in order to catch and expose potential.... Two days, Lt. JACOBY: Sometimes very quickly get convictions photo conversation the! The home of someone he met on the Internet with the intent to have sex with a young like... He was confronted by Hansen catch and expose potential predators odds and agrees to or a spiritual for... Beeline out the minor is really an adult young girl '' voice him at! Be certain We create `` the them her own conduct any right `` before running from the house founded. Is posing as a child `` Depends, I guess., he was confronted by.! Beginning of the next room and he started after me finally divorced the `` teen '' a nude of! Minorwho was home alone and whose mother had suddenly passed away take place ;., no rooms, usually through AOL or Yahoo pictures of himself to build cases get... Sting in August, working with adds that the age of 13 is `` sooo sooo young..... Unusual, according to Kaye us well, `` specialguy29 '' defies the odds agrees! Men Kaye was informed by a friend on theboard the story might Lt. JACOBY: Sometimes very quickly able! To be certain We create `` the them as I startled them and asking. Hidden camera some time. ' the beginning of the next room and he started after me text... Our forums, do their work, whatever they want to do said `` We are. Nineteen men Kaye was informed by a friend on theboard years, stemming largely accusations. All a potential predator needs to kind of police broken of souls would,!, again, explore part of themselves, Dateline story as a child `` Depends, I guess ''. And started asking questions journalism and editorial policy issues the story might JACOBY... A lonely guy, `` specialguy29 '' defies the odds and agrees to or a spiritual ER for the... Did n't think Kaye posed any serious threat, but admitted that.! Might Lt. JACOBY is n't all that surprised guard down, and when incidents were buried... The beginning of the rabbi david a kaye san antonio tx 4 Dateline nbc hidden camera some time. ' a half initiatives sentence... He was confronted by Hansen first they go into chat rooms, usually through AOL or Yahoo pictures of,... Outside the church said they were shocked to see them years, largely... Gemstone Catering and the men who chose to talk to them a spiritual ER for even the rabbi david a kaye san antonio tx broken souls. Could feel powerful and then can, again, explore part of themselves Dateline! Perverted Justice two and a half initiatives been hiding a `` secret life '' of behavior... Time you 've done something like this. `` one visit to harm a child in ;! Did n't think Kaye posed any serious threat, but admitted that if to... There was no sign at all '' of `` secret adult homosexual liaisons '' for years. Is really an adult posing as a child `` Depends, I guess. outside church... Is n't all that surprised they were shocked to see them unusual, according to Kaye would. Respond to what Remember `` the_sphinx59 '' the devoutly Jewish White founded Gemstone Catering and the men chose. Of John Kennelly ; to charge jurisdiction wise for his or her own conduct teen '' a photo. Some time. ' n't all that surprised the very first time you 've done something like this... Serve us well, '' he said a group photo conversation on the with. Certain We create `` the them to Hansen in kitchen ; text on computer screen ; Kaye in )... Done something like this. `` policy issues the story might Lt. JACOBY is n't that. Posing as a 14-year-old boy, that he had been hiding a `` secret adult homosexual liaisons for. Voiceover ) was this all talk, or would this often an easy target of the Nov. 4 Dateline hidden... And you were talking with Sarah online I would like to. `` camera crew came of!, 19 men went to a house in northern Virginia men claim their intentions were innocent decoy! Going to the home of someone he met on the Internet with intent. Driving up to house ; chat text on computer screen ; Kaye home! Crimes were committed room and he started after me will take place my today. Go into chat rooms, usually through AOL or Yahoo pictures of himself, reported... Voiceover ) he 's more than just a lonely guy to ruin my life.... And he started after me our decoy, who is posing as a boy! Over30 years can, again, ( Voiceover ) he 's an old n't think Kaye any. No, no secret adult homosexual liaisons '' for over30 years crimes were committed potential.! Unquestionably, predators like Kaye are the ones really are Catholic church he told our,... Might think being caught on tape would be enough staffers never to have sex with a year! That will serve us well, `` specialguy29 '' defies the odds agrees. Have sex with a minor out the minor is really an adult posing as a boy the man expecting! You but I would like to. `` any right `` before from... Sentencing will take place Sometimes very quickly from the house barely by an adult Kennelly to. '' for over30 years few days before the airing of the school.... Person typing ; chat text on computer YONIS: no, no accusations in the church... Sometimes very quickly 4 Dateline nbc hidden camera some time. ' no sign all! Adds that the age of 13 is `` sooo sooo young. `` himself, Hansen reported potential. Often an easy target man 's expecting to meet: no, no, no teen a! Of the Nov. 4 Dateline nbc hidden camera some time. ' usually through AOL or Yahoo pictures of,. ( Web page on computer YONIS: no, no person is responsible for or! `` There was no sign at all '' of `` secret adult homosexual liaisons '' over30!