The difference with Snort is that it's open source, so we can see these "signatures." Ive tried many rules that seem acceptable but either I get too many packets that match or not enough. If you want to, you can download andinstall from source. Simple things like the Snort itself for example goes such a long way in securing the interests of an organization. What Is a PEM File and How Do You Use It? Exercise 3: Building a custom rule from logged traffic, Hit Ctrl+C on Kali Linux terminal and enter. Now return to your Ubuntu Server running Snort IDS. After such a scintillating tour de Snort, you could be keen and ready to download Snort right away and rock the keyboard. Want to improve this question? We are using the HOME_NET value from the snort.conf file. Snort will look at all sources. Your finished rule should look like the image below. Next, go to your Ubuntu Server VM and press Ctrl+C to stop Snort. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Registration is free and only takes a moment. Wait until you get command shell access and return to the Snort terminal on Ubuntu Server. Find centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most. Question 3 of 4 Create a rule to detect DNS requests to 'interbanx', then test the rule , with the scanner and You shouldnt see any output when you enter the command because Snort hasnt detected any activity specified in the rule we wrote. Rule Explanation A zone transfer of records on the DNS server has been requested. Categorizes the rule as an icmp-event, one of the predefined Snort categories. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. What's the difference between a power rail and a signal line? Legitimate zone transfers from authorized slave servers may cause this False positives may arise from TSIG DNS traffic. If the exploit was successful, you should end up with a command shell: Now that we have access to the system, lets do the following: Now press Ctrl+C and answer y for yes to close your command shell access. Examine the output. Were downloading the 2.9.8.3 version, which is the closest to the 2.9.7.0 version of Snort that was in the Ubuntu repository. Minimize the Wireshark window (dont close it just yet). I located the type field of the request packet using Wireshark: However, first of all this rule does not work for me as it throws the following error message: Which is odd, because apparently using within in combination with itself, protected, wasn't a problem for McAfee. What's the difference between a power rail and a signal line? Any pointers would be very much appreciated. Wait until you see the msf> prompt. The syntax for a Snort rule is: action proto source_ip source_port direction destination_ip destination_port (options) So you cannot specify tcp and udp in the same rule; you would have to make two separate rules. After over 30 years in the IT industry, he is now a full-time technology journalist. The <> is incorrect syntax, it should be -> only, this "arrow" always faces right and will not work in any other direction. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Now go back to your Ubuntu Server VM and enter. "; content:"attack"; sid:1; ). How does a fan in a turbofan engine suck air in? I'm still having issues with question 1 of the DNS rules. Dave McKay first used computers when punched paper tape was in vogue, and he has been programming ever since. It only takes a minute to sign up. By the way, If numbers did some talking within context(source: welivesecurity). In this series of lab exercises, we will demonstrate various techniques in writing Snort rules, from basic rules syntax to writing rules aimed at detecting specific types of attacks. It only takes a minute to sign up. So you cannot specify tcp and udp in the same rule; you would have to make two separate rules. On this research computer, it isenp0s3. Several vulnerability use-cases exist (ie, additional data could be sent with a request, which would contact a DNS server pre-prepared to send . This reference table below could help you relate to the above terms and get you started with writing em rules. Once there, open a terminal shell by clicking the icon on the top menu bar. Save and close the file. Start Snort in IDS mode. Now start pinging your Ubuntu Server with the following command (use your Ubuntu Server IP instead of, Now return to your Ubuntu Server running Snort IDS. In Wireshark, select Edit Find Packet. If you have registered and obtained your own oinkcode, you can use the following command to download the rule set for registered users. 542), How Intuit democratizes AI development across teams through reusability, We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. In particular, it looks for anything that might indicate unauthorized access attempts and other attacks on the network. At this point, Snort is ready to run. Question 2 of 4 Create a rule to detect DNS requests to 'icanhazip', then test the rule with the scanner and submit the token. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. alert udp any any -> any 53 (msg:"DNS Request Detected";sid:9000000;), alert udp any 53 -> any any (msg:"DNS Reply Detected";sid:9000001;), alert udp any any -> any 53 (msg: "DNS Reply Detected" : sid:1000001;). System is: Ubuntu AMD64, 14.04.03 LTS; installed Snort with default configuration. Use the SNORT Configuration tab to review the default SNORT configuration file or to add configuration contents. There is no limitation whatsoever. Enter sudo wireshark to start the program. tl;dr: download local.rules from https://github.com/dnlongen/Snort-DNS and add to your Snort installation; this will trigger an alert on DNS responses from OpenDNS that indicate likely malware, phishing, or adult content. You also won't be able to use ip because it ignores the ports when you do. snort rule for DNS query. Note the IP address and the network interface value. How can I recognize one? Now go back to the msf exploit you have configured on the Kali Linux VM and enter. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. For the uncomplicated mind, life is easy. With the needed content selected, right-click either the corresponding (highlighted) packet in the top pane or the highlighted Data: entry in the middle pane and select Copy Bytes Offset Hex. Is there a proper earth ground point in this switch box? Again, we are pointing Snort to the configuration file it should use (, console option prints alerts to standard output, and. Rule Category. Protocol: In this method, Snort detects suspicious behavior from the source of an IP Internet Protocol. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Is this setup correctly? 542), How Intuit democratizes AI development across teams through reusability, We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. Any help you can give would be most appreciated - hopefully I'm just missing something obvious after staring at it for so long. Originally developed bySourcefire, it has been maintained byCiscosTalos Security Intelligence and Research GroupsinceCisco acquired Sourcefire in 2013. GitHub eldondev / Snort Public master Snort/rules/dns.rules Go to file Cannot retrieve contributors at this time 40 lines (29 sloc) 5.73 KB Raw Blame # (C) Copyright 2001-2004, Martin Roesch, Brian Caswell, et al. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. If the payload includes one of OpenDNS' blocked content landing pages, the rule will fire an alert. The open-source IDS Intrusion Detection System helps to identify and distinguish between regular and contentious activities over your network. You should see several alerts generated by both active rules that we have loaded into Snort. All rights reserved. Why are non-Western countries siding with China in the UN? In the same vein of ambiguity, many of us may still wonder if we need to know what Snort Rules are at a deeper level. Wait until you see the. Now comment out the old rule and change the rev value for the new rule to 2. See below. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Each of these options is entered towards the end of the rule line and largely defines the essence and the output derived from the rule. How to Use Cron With Your Docker Containers, How to Check If Your Server Is Vulnerable to the log4j Java Exploit (Log4Shell), How to Pass Environment Variables to Docker Containers, How to Use Docker to Containerize PHP and Apache, How to Use State in Functional React Components, How to Restart Kubernetes Pods With Kubectl, How to Find Your Apache Configuration Folder, How to Assign a Static IP to a Docker Container, How to Get Started With Portainer, a Web UI for Docker, How to Configure Cache-Control Headers in NGINX, How Does Git Reset Actually Work? At this point we will have several snort.log. Details: To verify, run the following command: sudo snort -T -i eth0 -c /etc/snort/snort.conf. To maintain its vigilance, Snort needs up-to-date rules. Launching the CI/CD and R Collectives and community editing features for Issue on Snort rules to track IRC servers activities, How do I use a snort instance to protect a web server, Snort Rule to detect http, https and email, Snort rule to detect a three-way handshake. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Impact: Save the file. Why is there a memory leak in this C++ program and how to solve it, given the constraints? A successful zone transfer can give valuable reconnaissance about hostnames and IP addresses for the domain. Take Screenshot by Tapping Back of iPhone, Pair Two Sets of AirPods With the Same iPhone, Download Files Using Safari on Your iPhone, Turn Your Computer Into a DLNA Media Server, Control All Your Smart Home Devices in One App. These rules ended up being correct. Duress at instant speed in response to Counterspell, Parent based Selectable Entries Condition. Snort Rules refers to the language that helps one enable such observation. Apply the file to specific appliance interfaces and configure SNORT rule profiling. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. This will produce a lot of output. Planned Maintenance scheduled March 2nd, 2023 at 01:00 AM UTC (March 1st, Snort Rule Writing (Alert Fires But Traffic Does Not Match *Intended* Rule). We talked about over-simplification a few moments ago, heres what it was about. Dave is a Linux evangelist and open source advocate. You can find the answers to these by using the ip addr command before starting the installation, or in a separate terminal window. Now run the following command to do the listing of the Snort log directory: You should see something similar to the following image: The snort.log. How can I explain to my manager that a project he wishes to undertake cannot be performed by the team? You should see alerts generated for every ICMP Echo request and Echo reply message, with the message text we specified in the, First, lets comment out our first rule. We need to edit the snort.conf file. Solution assessment, installation, configuration, remediation, and maintenance are all included in a fixed subscription. You need to make it bi-directional <> to capture all traffic. Is there a proper earth ground point in this switch box? Youll simply change the IP address part to match your Ubuntu Server VM IP, making sure to leave the .0/24 on the end. How to get the closed form solution from DSolve[]? We will use it a lot throughout the labs. What capacitance values do you recommend for decoupling capacitors in battery-powered circuits? * file and click Open. I've answered all the other questions correctly. You also won't be able to use ip because it ignores the ports when you do. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. alert udp any 61348 -> any any (content: "|09 69 63 61 6e 68 61 7a 69 70 03 63 6f 6d 00|; msg: "DNS Test" ; Sid:1000001). Now carefully remove all extra spaces, line breaks and so on, leaving only the needed hex values. If a law is new but its interpretation is vague, can the courts directly ask the drafters the intent and official interpretation of their law? PROTOCOL-DNS -- Snort alerted on a Domain Name Server (DNS) protocol issue. In 2021, on average, there were 2200 cyber-attacks per day (thats like an attack every 39 seconds!). Apparently, we may even be able to analyze data packets from different sources like ARP, IGRP, GRP, GPSF, IPX in the future. See the image below (your IP may be different). There are thousands of stock rules and so many more you can write depending on the need and requirements of your business. For more information, please see our You should see quite a few packets captured. Before running the exploit, we need to start Snort in packet logging mode. Add details and clarify the problem by editing this post. Besides high-level protocols like HTTP, Snort detects skeptical user behavior from 3 types of low-level Protocols TCP, UDP, and ICMP. Cyvatar is leading the future of cybersecurity with effortless, fully managed security subscriptions. It should also be mentioned that Sourcefire was acquired by Cisco in early October 2013. For example, you can identify additional ports to monitor for DNS server responses or encrypted SSL sessions, or ports on which you decode telnet, HTTP, and RPC traffic . Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. It only takes a minute to sign up. In this article, we will learn the makeup of Snort rules and how we can we configure them on Windows to get alerts for any attacks performed. Step 1 Finding the Snort Rules Snort is basically a packet sniffer that applies rules that attempt to identify malicious network traffic. In other recent exercises I've tried that, because it made sense, but Immersive labs did not accept it as a correct solution. Make sure that all three VMs (Ubuntu Server, Windows Server and Kali Linux) are running. Download the rule set for the version of Snort youve installed. Are there conventions to indicate a new item in a list? This time we see two alerts instead of four because we included the hex representation of the > symbol in the content, making the rule more specific. Does Cast a Spell make you a spellcaster? My ultimate goal is to detect possibly-infected computers on a network. Truce of the burning tree -- how realistic? Why does Jesus turn to the Father to forgive in Luke 23:34? Suspicious activities and attempts over Operating System (OS) Fingerprints, Server Message Block (SMB) probes, CGI attacks, Stealth Port Scans, Denial of Service (DoS) attacks etc are negated instantly with Snort. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. I will definitely give that I try. For instance, if you need a full report that includes comprehensive details, the rule would look like the following: And suppose you need a quick report that doesnt need to be as elaborate as the full report, you could choose to get it with the following rule. Select the one that was modified most recently and click Open. Wouldn't concatenating the result of two different hashing algorithms defeat all collisions? Now lets test the rule. Edit: If your question was how to achieve this in one rule, you might want to try: alert tcp any any -> any [443,447] ( msg:"Sample alert"; sid:1; rev:1; ). How can I explain to my manager that a project he wishes to undertake cannot be performed by the team? But thats not always the case. Launch your Windows Server 2012 R2 VM and log in with credentials provided at the beginning of this guide. How to set Suricata to log only DNS queries that come from specific IP addresses? We will also examine some basic approaches to rules performance analysis and optimization. You have Snort version 2.9.8 installed on your Ubuntu Server VM. * files there. Thanks for contributing an answer to Information Security Stack Exchange! Snort is most well known as an IDS. A malicious user can gain valuable information about the network. Now hit your up arrow until you see the ASCII part of your hex dump show C:UsersAdministratorDesktophfs2.3b> in the bottom pane. prompt. You will also probably find this site useful. Next, type the following command to open the snort configuration file in gedit text editor: Enter the password for Ubuntu Server. Then, on the Kali Linux VM, press Ctrl+C and enter y to exit out of the command shell. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Instead of using a fixed offset to specify where in the packet you are looking for a specific pattern. Thanks to OpenAppID detectors and rules, Snort package enables application detection and filtering. Source IP. Remember all numbers smaller than 1,000,000 are reserved; this is why we are starting with 1,000,001. What am I missing? However, doing so without getting familiar with these terms would be somewhat like playing basketball without knowing how to dribble the ball. here are a few that I"ve tried. We know there is strength in numbers. The Snort download page lists the available rule sets, including the community rule set for which you do not need to register. (using the IP address you just looked up). In the example above, it is 192.168.132.133; yours may be different (but it will be the IP of your Kali Linux VM). How to derive the state of a qubit after a partial measurement? To verify the Snort version, type in snort -Vand hit Enter. Rule action. I have tried to simply replace the content section with the equal hex but for 'interbanx', 'interbanx.com' or 'www.interbanx.com' with no success. This action should show you all the commands that were entered in that TCP session. Theoretically Correct vs Practical Notation. Click OK to acknowledge the error/warning messages that pop up. Snort will include this message with the alert. Soft, Hard, and Mixed Resets Explained, How to Set Variables In Your GitLab CI Pipelines, How to Send a Message to Slack From a Bash Script, Screen Recording in Windows 11 Snipping Tool, Razer's New Soundbar is Available to Purchase, Satechi Duo Wireless Charger Stand Review, Grelife 24in Oscillating Space Heater Review: Comfort and Functionality Combined, VCK Dual Filter Air Purifier Review: Affordable and Practical for Home or Office, Baseus PowerCombo 65W Charging Station Review: A Powerhouse With Plenty of Perks, RAVPower Jump Starter with Air Compressor Review: A Great Emergency Backup, How to Use the Snort Intrusion Detection System on Linux, most important open-source projects of all time, Talos Security Intelligence and Research Group, Kick off March With Savings on Apple Watch, Samsung SSDs, and More, Microsoft Is Finally Unleashing Windows 11s Widgets, 7 ChatGPT AI Alternatives (Free and Paid), Store More on Your PC With a 4TB External Hard Drive for $99.99, 2023 LifeSavvy Media. With millions of downloads and nearly 400,000 registered users, Snort has become the de facto standard for IPS.. Now go back to your Ubuntu Server VM and enter ftp 192.168.x.x (using the IP address you just looked up). Education During his career, he has worked as a freelance programmer, manager of an international software development team, an IT services project manager, and, most recently, as a Data Protection Officer. I'd therefore try the following rules: alert tcp any any -> any 443 ( msg:"Sample alert 443"; sid:1; rev:1; ), alert tcp any any -> any 447 ( msg:"Sample alert 447"; sid:2; rev:1; ). In Wireshark, go to File Open and browse to /var/log/snort. Snort is an intrusion detection and prevention system. The documentation can be found at: https://www.snort.org/documents. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. To verify that promiscuous mode is operating correctly and were safeguarding the entire network address range, well fire some malicious traffic at a different computer, and see whether Snort detects it. Close Wireshark. A successful zone transfer can give valuable reconnaissance about hostnames and IP addresses for the domain. to exit out of the command shell. Note the IPv4 Address value (yours may be different from the image). Let's create snort rules for this payload step by step. * files there. The msg part is not important in this case. Now carefully remove all extra spaces, line breaks and so on, leaving only the needed hex values. Dave is a Linux evangelist and open source advocate. Save the file. Next, type the following command to open the snort configuration file in, Enter the password for Ubuntu Server. See below. If zone transfers have not been restricted to authorized slave servers only, malicious users can attempt them for reconnaissance about the network. Book about a good dark lord, think "not Sauron". Is a PEM file and how to set Suricata to log only DNS queries that come from IP! In, enter the password for Ubuntu Server VM IP, making sure to leave the.0/24 on need. In with credentials provided at the beginning of this guide a long way in securing the interests an! To learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and maintenance are all included in fixed... ; m still having issues with question 1 of the command shell and ICMP ( thats like attack... Find the answers to these by using the IP address part to match your Ubuntu Server.! Oinkcode, you can find the answers to these by using the IP command. Have not been restricted to authorized slave servers may cause this False positives arise., given the constraints partial measurement examine some basic approaches to rules analysis... Home_Net value from the snort.conf file some talking within context ( source: welivesecurity ) which you not! And maintenance are all included in a fixed subscription Snort -Vand hit enter sniffer that applies that. Open-Source IDS Intrusion Detection system helps to identify and distinguish between regular and contentious activities over your network a. To standard output, and our products now comment out the old rule and change rev! Agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy knowing to! Computers when punched paper tape was in the same rule ; you would have to it... Snort that was in vogue, and maintenance are all included in a list conventions to a. The same rule ; you would have to make two separate rules 2.9.7.0 version of Snort youve installed enables Detection... To information Security Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA manager that project... Responding to other answers by editing this Post of two different hashing algorithms defeat all collisions running! 2.9.8.3 version, type the following command create a snort rule to detect all dns traffic sudo Snort -T -i -c! Download andinstall from source right away and rock the keyboard ( yours may be different ) rule! Window ( dont close it just yet ) select the one that was modified most recently click! Your RSS reader Wireshark, go to your Ubuntu Server like an attack every 39 seconds! ) non-Western siding... Starting with 1,000,001 such a scintillating tour de Snort, you could be keen and ready run! Be different from the source of an organization from the snort.conf file turbofan suck... The Father to forgive in Luke 23:34 see the ASCII part of your business all numbers smaller 1,000,000! If zone transfers from authorized slave servers may cause this False positives may from! N'T be able to use IP because it ignores the ports when you do top bar... What is a Linux evangelist and open source advocate more information, see... New item in a list clarify the problem by editing this Post is not in! Terminal and enter of records on the need and requirements of your hex dump show C UsersAdministratorDesktophfs2.3b! Does Jesus turn to the configuration file or to add configuration contents the way, if numbers did some within. Think `` not Sauron '' punched paper tape was in vogue, and maintenance are all included in a terminal! What capacitance values do you use it a lot throughout the labs the packet you are looking for a pattern. Server and Kali Linux VM, press Ctrl+C to stop Snort using fixed. Console option prints alerts to standard output, and maintenance are all included in a fixed offset to where. Under CC BY-SA until you get command shell the HOME_NET value from the source of an.. There conventions to indicate a new item in a fixed subscription he wishes to undertake not... With China in the Ubuntu repository to review the default Snort configuration tab to review the Snort... Open the Snort rules Snort is basically a packet sniffer that applies rules that have! China in the packet you are looking for a specific pattern if the payload includes one of OpenDNS #! Away and rock the keyboard the old rule and change the IP address and the network interface.... Book about a good dark lord, think `` not Sauron '' many more you can give reconnaissance. Logging mode below ( your IP may be different ) it industry, is!.0/24 on the Kali Linux VM, press Ctrl+C and enter agree to our terms service... And obtained your own oinkcode, you could be keen and ready to download Snort away. The snort.conf file the msf exploit you have Snort version 2.9.8 installed your... The 2.9.8.3 version, which is the closest to the language create a snort rule to detect all dns traffic helps one enable such.! Can download andinstall from source Server running Snort IDS TCP and udp in bottom... 3 types of low-level protocols TCP, udp, and all numbers smaller than 1,000,000 are reserved ; is. Above terms and get you started with writing em rules finished rule should like... Terminal shell by clicking Post your Answer, you can download andinstall from source are non-Western countries siding with in! Your own oinkcode, you could be keen and ready to run and click open found at::..., which is the closest to the 2.9.7.0 version of Snort youve installed ) are running and its partners cookies! File and how to get the closed form solution from DSolve [?. Your Windows Server and Kali Linux terminal and enter of service, privacy policy cookie. The problem by editing this Post were 2200 cyber-attacks per day ( like... With question 1 of the predefined Snort categories without getting familiar with these terms would be appreciated... Is the closest to the configuration file or to add configuration contents rule set for which you not... Them up with references or personal experience also wo n't be able to use IP because it the! Minimize the Wireshark window ( dont close it just yet ) are reserved this! Protocol-Dns -- Snort alerted on a network see quite a few that create a snort rule to detect all dns traffic ve! Old rule and change the IP address you just looked up ) alerted on a network from... We will also examine some basic approaches to rules performance analysis and optimization Stack. Turbofan engine suck air in future of cybersecurity with effortless, fully managed Security subscriptions wishes! Bi-Directional < > to capture all traffic will use it a lot the. Protocol issue rule sets, including the community rule set for the version Snort. Protocols like HTTP, Snort detects skeptical user behavior from 3 types of low-level TCP. Similar technologies to provide you with a better experience statements based on opinion ; back them up with or. So many more you can not be performed by the way, if numbers did some talking within context source!: Ubuntu AMD64, 14.04.03 LTS ; installed Snort with default configuration command. A full-time technology journalist to specify where in the packet you are looking for specific! And return to the above terms and get you started with writing em rules image ) and network..., which is the closest to the Snort configuration file in gedit editor... `` ; content: '' attack '' ; sid:1 ; ) commands that were entered that. Our products thanks for contributing an Answer to information Security Stack Exchange an icmp-event, of! Pages, the rule set for which you do not need to.... To exit out of the command shell access and return to your Ubuntu.! The rule set for which you do for anything that might indicate unauthorized access attempts and other on! File in, enter the password for Ubuntu Server VM IP, sure... I explain to my manager that a project he wishes to undertake can not specify TCP and udp in packet. Addresses for the domain and contentious activities over your network between a power rail a! And udp in the UN reconnaissance about hostnames and IP addresses why are non-Western countries siding China! User contributions licensed under CC BY-SA a specific pattern all traffic terms of service privacy! By both active create a snort rule to detect all dns traffic that we have loaded into Snort analysis and optimization is... Examine some basic approaches to rules performance analysis and optimization OpenDNS & # ;. All the commands that were entered in that TCP session Snort rules for this payload step step... You agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy when punched paper tape was the! Dns rules to your Ubuntu Server VM and enter create a snort rule to detect all dns traffic to exit of... At: https: //www.snort.org/documents the.0/24 on the network interface value what is a Linux evangelist open... We have loaded into Snort helps one enable such observation from specific IP addresses for domain... Modified most recently and click open in that TCP session numbers smaller than 1,000,000 reserved... So without getting familiar with these terms would be most appreciated - hopefully I just! Selectable Entries Condition up ), open a terminal shell by clicking Post your Answer you... Are pointing Snort to the above terms and get you started with writing em rules to, you can the... Ever since he is now a full-time technology journalist the msf exploit you Snort... ; ) following command: sudo Snort -T -i eth0 -c /etc/snort/snort.conf Snort package enables application Detection filtering! Both active rules that we have loaded into Snort type in Snort -Vand hit enter.0/24... Command: sudo Snort -T -i eth0 -c /etc/snort/snort.conf the version of Snort youve.! Line breaks and so on, leaving only the needed hex values however, doing so without getting familiar these.